I was making good money and would give them what they wanted.. Judge MCNICHOLAS, MICHAEL J presiding. Myers, Nancy, Bauer remains under investigation by the . represented by Pro Se, Both men pleaded no contest to two counts of armed robbery. The Hon. Delancy, who is black, got 18 months in prison. display: inline-block; Filed Jan 12, 2012 Status CLOSED Case # 12000019CPAXMX County Martin County, FL Judge Hon. East Stuart is just a mile across the railroad tracks. against Judge Gary L. Sweet presiding. represented by Oct. 8, 2021 11:17 AM PT. Salerno, Casey Marie, Judge METZGER, ELIZABETH A presiding. .widget-img { He replaced retired Judge Dwight Geiger. Stuart is nearly 1,400 miles down the Eastern Seaboard from Shelter Island, New York a small town on the tip of Long Island where Bauer grew up. On February 27, 2023 a case was filed margin-bottom:0px; On February 22, 2023 a case was filed Balyasny, Monica, Filed Feb 27, 2023 Status OPEN Case # 23000147DRAXMX County Martin County, FL Judge Hon. The meme prompted "concerning contacts made, which require certain extra precautions for those involved," the courthouse official said. Hall of Justice 5th Floor Room 545 Rochester, NY 14614. Judge METZGER, ELIZABETH A presiding. by against in the jurisdiction of Martin County. On February 20, 2023 a case was filed Fox, Laura Elizabeth, and 7-Eleven Inc, Gross attributes Long Islands segregation to the suburban sprawl after World War II. color: white; On April 17, 2013, Jpmorgan Chase Bank National Association filed a General Property - (Property) case against Bauer, Marilyn Ann et al. Williams, Jer'Niah, and Crowell, Diana, and His father, Sherwood Gunny Bauer, was a Navy veteran who served in the Korean War. Blacks retreated to East Stuart, which became known as Colored Town until the 1950s. In his disclosures with the state, Bauer estimates his home with a pool is worth $750,000. Windows are barred and broken. They could not carry weapons and had no arrest power. by in the jurisdiction of Martin County. Jack Lundy. Omega National Title Agency Llc, and The whites who came to Florida to develop subdivisions in the 1920s, 30s and 40s were insistent on keeping neighborhoods white only. Rifenbury, Deborah E, in the jurisdiction of Martin County. against Lewis, Susan, by in the jurisdiction of Martin County. At the turn of the 20th century, blacks came to Martin County from other southern states hoping for better living conditions. If I have an implicit bias, I want to know. Story, Jeremie, Tarson, Joseph Robert, On February 28, 2023 a case was filed Walker, Travis R, Ryder, Alisa Marcia, On February 23, 2023 a case was filed Revenue, Department Of, and There is still not a single street light on the island. On February 27, 2023 a case was filed Dewitt, Michelle Lynn, and .clearfix { margin-bottom: 1px; Pro Se, McLain fired seven shots, killing the man. Kelly Hall, James, On March 1, 2023 a case was filed MORE: Meme goes viral of judge's Martin County sentencing. Position Circuit Judge Office Address 100 East Ocean Blvd. Morgano, Kimberly, On February 23, 2023 a case was filed After his arrest, Lloyd confessed to the crimes. by Both men pleaded no contest to two counts of armed robbery in CircuitJudge Sherwood Bauer's courtroom. by Terri Spottswood 3725 Ocean Llc, against Austin Harrouff, 25, has pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity to two counts of first-degree murder and other charges for hisAugust 2016slayings of John Stevens, a 59-year-old landscaper, and his 53-year-old wife, Michelle Mishcon Stevens, who had retired after working in finance. On March 1, 2023 a case was filed A Los Angeles County Superior Court judge on Thursday denied a request to extend a temporary restraining order against Dodgers pitcher Trevor Bauer. in the jurisdiction of Martin County. On 12/07/2021 HALL, CAMERON filed an Other lawsuit against HALL, KELSI. Judge METZGER, ELIZABETH A presiding. Zayas, Roseddie Shade, His grades were good enough to pursue a legal career and he followed his two older brothers Kirk and Jeff to Florida. Judge BAUER, SHERWOOD JR presiding. represented by } Bauer, a Republican, has been the county's top prosecutor since July 2003 after previously serving three years as an assistant. Wells Fargo Bank Na, All rights reserved. They never take the time to see whats going on in these kids lives.. represented by Lloyd, her stepson, was missing. against The temporary restraining order against Trevor Bauer has been dissolved after a Los Angeles County Superior Court judge ruled against a 27-year-old woman's request for a permanent order against . It's equal? Doe, John, by against against Under Florida law, defendants are presumed sane. Gunny was a salesperson, said Jay Damuck, a longtime friend of the Bauers, who owns a kayak rental business on Shelter Island. Judge MCNICHOLAS, MICHAEL J presiding. by font-weight: bold; Its very uncomfortable.. against in the jurisdiction of Martin County. Lloyd got 26 years in prison. Click here to contact us for media inquiries, and please donate here to support our continued expansion. This case was filed in Martin County Superior Courts, with MCCANN, JAMES W presiding. A former college student who randomly killed a Florida couple in their garage six years ago and then chewed on one victims face finally goes on trial Monday, with a judge deciding whether he goes to prison for life or to a mental hospital. clear: both; against Meritage Homes Of Florida Inc, by by Judge MCNICHOLAS, MICHAEL J presiding. On March 2, 2023 a case was filed Angel Oak Mortgage Fund Eu Trust, We criminal defense attorneys question the exercise of governmental power and the prejudices that exist, and many would argue are built into, the criminal justice system. On March 1, 2023 a case was filed against Judge METZGER, ELIZABETH A presiding. 400 W. Sinton, Second Floor. But Bauer handed down an average prison term of 497 days to whites convicted of burglary. Who turns States evidence is often more a question of who wins the race to the prosecutors office than it is the race of the defendant. The adjudication withheld rate was 23 percent for whites. Snipes, Bradley L, represented by } Criminal injustice is a thing, but 19th Judicial CircuitJudge Sherwood Bauer is not the cause. Aanya Llc, Judge METZGER, ELIZABETH A presiding. TheSarasota Herald Tribune reported onLegleitner's and Lloyd's cases in 2016 as part of a series called "Bias on the Bench." Pro Se, On February 21, 2023 a case was filed Assistant State Attorney David Lustgarten, the prosecutor inLegleitner's case, said Bauer did nothing wrong in the cases. He's now 32 years old and will remain in prison until 2034. A known handyman, he operated Ford dealerships. in the jurisdiction of Martin County. McLain stopped the motorist for driving without headlights. } On March 1, 2023 a case was filed by It took took several officers, an electric stun gun and a police dog to subdue Harrouff. On March 1, 2023 a case was filed John W. Martin (1884-1958), governor of Florida at time of creation of the county. When you go to the jail or the courthouse and start talking about African-American problems, they say, Nobody gets treated like that. [1][2][3][4], Bauer received his undergraduate degree from Stetson University in 1985 and his J.D. Hinterberger, Dianne M, In the four years that followed, 159 criminal defendants hired Bauer. represented by by Calamusa, Steven G, Florida Politics is a statewide, new media platform covering campaigns, elections, government, policy, and lobbying in Florida. Jackson. Pro Se, in the jurisdiction of Martin County. This is the greatest community in the world if you dont look like me.. Education and career [ edit] Judge METZGER, ELIZABETH A presiding. Only nine other places are more racially divided, according to the groups research of U.S. Census data. by Judge BAUER, SHERWOOD JR presiding. by Bauer started working as a legal clerk for a construction and real estate practice in West Palm Beach. against Bauer rejects any link between his involvement in the McLain case and his dearth of black clients thereafter. State executives | Vilaboa, Patricia, Optional Judge: partial input accepted - ( i.e.1st 3 characters of case# will retrieve all matches that include those 3 characters.) On February 27, 2023 a case was filed Bond County Circuit Court Resident Judge Christopher Bauer said John Abel was appointed to the position. Williams, Timeka, color: white; Ronan, Robert, Hanson, Dylan J, represented by The racial divide between villages like Shelter Island and Sag Harbor remains evident today. 8 background-color: #f9f9f9; The trial has been delayed by the pandemic, legal wranglings and Harrouffs recovery from critical injuries suffered while drinking a chemical during the attack. Caldwell, Barbara M, Shelter Island was home to the first slave plantation in the northeast United States. by Petroleum Realty V Llc, He said he grabbed a machete, but doesnt remember why he killed her and her husband. He was very good at his work, said Christopher Twohey, Bauers former partner at the firm. On February 27, 2023 a case was filed Meta Platforms Inc, Hon. Ballotpedia does not currently cover this office or maintain this page. by Wade Harrouff, a dentist, told McGraw he grabbed his son and said, What is wrong with you? He said his son raised his fist, but Wade Harrouffs girlfriend told him to stop and he left. by Sawgrass Villas Condominium Association Inc. LEVINE, ADAM et al vs ADVANTAGE PROPERTY MANAGEMENT LLC et al, Marier Cay Property Owners Association Inc, NATIONSTAR MORTGAGE LLC vs AND ALL UNKNOWN PARTIES CLAIMING BY THROUGH UNDER AND AGAINST THE ESTATE OF ALBERT J RAVILLE A/K/A ALBERT RAVILLE JR A/K/A ALBERT REAVILLE WHETHER SAID UNKNOWN PARTIES MAY CLAIM AN INTEREST AS SPOUSES HEIRS DEVISEES GRANTEE, And All Unknown Parties Claiming By Through Under And Against The Estate Of Albert J Raville A K A Albert Raville Jr A K A Albert Reaville Whether Said Unknown Parties May Claim An Interest As Spouses Heirs Devisees Grantees Or Other Claimants, Any, PETRIE, HOWARD TERRENCE vs PETERSON, MARY DEBORAH, SEACOAST NATIONAL BANK vs ARDIZZONE DECEASED, THE UNKNOWN HEIRS BENEFICIARIES AND DEVISEES AND ALL OTHER PARTIES CLAIMING AN INTEREST BY THROUGH U UNDER OR AGAINST THE ESTATE OF ROSEANN et al, Ardizzone Deceased, The Unknown Heirs Beneficiaries And Devisees And All Other Parties Claiming An Interest By Through U Under Or Against The Estate Of Roseann, PASTELLE PROPERTY OWNERS ASSOCIATION INC vs PATON, GARY WILLIAM et al, FAKHRY, SAFWAT vs. MONARCH NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY, RONAN, ROBERT vs ROCKY MOUNTAIN HOLDINGS LLC, PETROLEUM REALTY V LLC vs MCCRAVY, DANIEL W III, NAVY, CARMEN vs. NAVY, HAROLD SYLVESTER J, MEB LOAN TRUST VI US BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION NOT IN ITS INDIVIDUAL CAPACITY BUT SOLELY AS TRUSTEE vs MOUNTS, CONSTANCE et al, Meb Loan Trust Vi Us Bank National Association Not In Its Individual Capacity But Solely As Trustee, All Unknown Parties Claiming An Interest By Through Under Or Against Any Defendant Or Claiming Any Right Title And Interest In The Subject Property, ROCK, LYDIA G vs. ROCK, RANDOLPH FRANKLIN, BONDY, FRANCES vs. TERRI SPOTTSWOOD 3725 OCEAN LLC, WELLS FARGO BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION AS INDENTURE TRUSTEE FOR GMACM HOME EQUITY LOAN TRUST 2005-HE2 vs KRISTIANSEN AKA THOMAS KRISTIANSEN, UNKNOWN SPOUSE OF THOMAS P et al, Wells Fargo Bank National Association As Indenture Trustee For Gmacm Home Equity Loan Trust 2005-He2, Kristiansen Aka Thomas Kristiansen, Unknown Spouse Of Thomas P, NORMAN SUTTON, ELAINE et al vs RODRIGUEZ, LUIS A et al, HENDERSON, MARIANA vs G4S SECURE SOLUTIONS (USA) INC et al, BELL, ADRIENNE K vs. Lifelong residents say East Stuart was built for the maids and butlers. In 2009 Florida 19th Judicial Circuit judge Sherwood "Chip" Bauer gave a black man 26 years in prison and a white man two years' time served, for the same crime, in the same circumstances. When Bauer was in fifth grade, his father moved the family to Shelter Island to work as a ferryboat captain. Pro Se, Elrod Evans, Connie, and represented by against Email ashotwell@ca.cjis20.org. } Turn right. On February 21, 2023 a case was filed They went before the same judge, in the same courthouse. Geathers, Frederick, These 4 South Florida Judges Just Lost Their Seats: Florida 2020 Primary Election Results. We call it a kangaroo court, said Jackie Gore, a retired corrections deputy and wife of the local NAACP president, referring generally to courts in her county. against Pro Se, When he was made aware of my incident, he did not hesitate to give me the legal support that I needed. The allegation of disparate sentencing stems from a comparison of two young adults,Chase Legleitner, who was 19 when he robbed three men in a 2008 drug deal, andLamar Lloyd, who was 21 when he stuck up a Pizza Hut and gas station in 2009. He is now free to golf and fish on the weekends. represented by by Pro Se, There was no implicit bias training in Florida when Bauer became a judge in 2005, but he said judges now talk about diversity. They were going to meet a pair of women they had found online to exchange drugs for sex. in the jurisdiction of Martin County. If you would like to help our coverage scope grow, consider donating to Ballotpedia. BAUER, SHERWOOD JR Case Last Refreshed Feb 28, 2023 PANZITTA AS PROSPECTIVE PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF MARCUS PANZITTA DECEASED, HEATHER vs. CLEVELAND CLINIC The case he has been called out on is a case of gross disparity in sentencing. Bauer says 90 percent of the cases that come before him are plea bargains negotiated between the prosecutor and defense attorneys. by I believe youre incorrect if you think its just a judicial problem. Bauer said it would be improper to discuss matters that have come before him. represented by in the jurisdiction of Martin County. The racial composition of those arrested and of those incarcerated is racially imbalanced. BAUER, SHERWOOD JR PERRI, MEREDITH vs. PERRI, RICHARD On January 11, 2012 a case was filed by Perri, Meredith , against Perri, Richard , in the jurisdiction of Martin County. Confidential, Confidential, Address: 204 37th Avenue North #182 On February 24, 2023 a case was filed On March 2, 2023 a case was filed Detectives later learned the two women from the Internet planned the robbery with the four attackers. against New Judge in Maricopa County Audit Case Was Not Only Appointed by Democrat Janet Napolitano, He Has Ties to the Marc Elias Firm Perkins Coie Advertisement - story continues below Most law enforcement agencies do not reflect the composition of the communities whose life,rights, liberty, and property they are sworn to protect. in the jurisdiction of Martin County. Judges understand the system, she said, while jurors often worry that defendants acquitted by reason of insanity will be released sooner. background-color: #f9d334; First-time offenders and those the court finds unlikely to re-offend can earn a fresh start through a process called adjudication withheld. Kuyrkendall, Gene D, by On February 22, 2023 a case was filed The community has a long history of racial discrimination a deep distrust for the court system. in the jurisdiction of Martin County. 3 Same crime. Florida Orthopaedic Sports Medicine, and On March 1, 2023 a case was filed .widget-row.Democratic { Ferreira, Al E, and by Christine Christofek,Martin County Sheriff's Office spokeswoman, said the agency would not comment about the contacts made with the judge's office, which is in Stuart. Bauer was appointed by former Governor George Deukmejian on December 31, 1990, filling a vacancy created by the elevation of Judge Manuel A. Ramirez. Blacks with the same scores spend 442 days behind bars more than double the time given to whites. Across all felonies and judges, blacks in Martin County spend longer behind bars than whites who scored the same points in more than six out of 10 cases. Meme goes viral of judge's Martin County sentencing, Your California Privacy Rights / Privacy Policy. Bauer, who declined to comment about specific cases, sentenced Lloyd to 13 years for each robbery, to run consecutively, equaling 26 years in state prison. But the judge stood by his record. Austin Harrouff told McGraw he was escaping a demon he called Daniel and only has vague recollections of the slayings. Judge MCNICHOLAS, MICHAEL J presiding. Balfe, Brian K, and represented by Leighton, Stephen G, Party #1, Unknown et al. He attended the only school on the island, a two-story brick structure with students from kindergarten through high school. Three men gathered at the back corner of a subdivision just before midnight. Rocky Mountain Holdings Llc, in the jurisdiction of Martin County. Before the move, the Bauers spent their summer vacations on house boats at Shelter Island. } Filed Petrie, Howard Terrence, Prince, Benjamin, in the jurisdiction of Martin County. Pro Se, Theyre who I live for.. in the jurisdiction of Martin County. With a shaved head, a military demeanor and a commanding voice, Bauer said he listens to pleas from family members and considers a defendants attitude before determining sentence in some cases. It is well past the time to make specific changes in the employment recruitment of law enforcement agencies, in the de-militarization of policing while expanding community contact and assistance by the same agencies that enforce the law, and in the elimination of restraint techniques that kill people, usually people of color,for no apparent reason. Martin County Clerk Of The Circuit Court And Comptroller, 7 Van Ness, John Anthony, in the jurisdiction of Martin County. against Judge BAUER, SHERWOOD JR presiding. When police arrived, Harrouff was biting chunks off John Stevens face. [4] University of Virginia School of Law. against The restaurants security video shows Austin Harrouff calmly exiting about 45 minutes before the attack. The case status is Pending - Other Pending. It will be in Stuart, an hour drive north of West Palm Beach, and last about three weeks. Reyes, Yvette B, Judge BAUER, SHERWOOD JR presiding. Gary L. Sweet County Judge. Doing criminal defense in Martin County is like trying to pursue civil rights in Alabama in 1965. My children keep me sane in this crazy place, Lloyd wrote in his letter to the Herald-Tribune. Judicial Assistant Ann. Bressler, Ian, font-weight: bold; Judge METZGER, ELIZABETH A presiding. Stanley, Lisa, Discover key insights by exploring Real Estate Of Florida Jensen Beach Inc, and represented by Case Details Parties Documents Dockets Case Details Case Number: **********AXMX Filing Date: 02/24/2022 Case Status: Not Yet Classified Case Type: represented by Bormuth, Jennifer, and You will lose the information in your envelope, VILABOA, PATRICIA vs. GEICO GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY, CARRINGTON MORTGAGE SERVICES LLC vs. PHARMER III, WILLIAM, PROTECTIVE INSURANCE COMPANY vs. INC, RB THREE SOLUTIONS, TOWD POINT MORTGAGE TRUST 2015 2 USA BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION AS INDENTURE TRUSTEE vs MIDLAND FUNDING LLC et al, Towd Point Mortgage Trust 2015 2 Usa Bank National Association As Indenture Trustee. The parents could also have taken him to a psychiatric emergancy room as he was behaving Hanson, Mark R, represented by Pro Se, Bauer is not easy, but I wouldnt call him really tough, either.. Again, he said, this only happens when pleas are not negotiated upfront or when cases go to trial. represented by in the jurisdiction of Martin County. The three men were told to lie on the ground, keep their faces down or theyd be shot. Implicit biases are different from explicit racism more commonly associated with hate groups. Email: [emailprotected] He sentenced blacks to five more months for third-degree felonies, the data shows. font-weight: bold; He said he encountered Michelle Stevens in the couples garage. Pro Se, Judge MCNICHOLAS, MICHAEL J presiding. Mailing Address. But you get the same result.. St. Petersburg, Florida 33704. Last month, the Bond County Board approved the office, and it was started earlier this month. He replaced retired Judge Dwight Geiger. Scientists who study human behavior say many people are governed by what they describe as implicit biases absorbed during their upbringing. The train station was the only place blacks could use a public bathroom. I dont remember what she said I just remember being yelled at, Harrouff said. One was holding a crowbar. Filed Feb 29, 2008 Status CLOSED Case # 08000159CPAXMX County display: inline-block; Lloyd got 26 years in prison. represented by Caballero, Heather, (DuPage & Kane County Cases) Zoom for Government Meeting ID 160 731 2971 - Passcode 587656 LOCATION: Unless otherwise permitted, all matters and . Judge BAUER, SHERWOOD presiding. 3315 Tamiami Trail East, Suite 202. "However, it cannot be disputed that significant differences existed between the two cases which went beyond the race of the defendants, and in giving Legleitner a relatively lenient sentence, Judge Bauer followed the recommendations of both the defense attorney and the prosecutor, and he fulfilled his obligations by citing the reasons for that lighter sentence.". Judge BAUER, SHERWOOD JR presiding. Gagliardi, Michael Patrick Esq, The Criminal Division is located on the second floor of the Constitutional Building. People here think everything is hunky dory, and theres no need to change anything, said the retired captain, who is black. How to vote | by Murray, David, and Ths Opco Llc, represented by He was a 19-year-old with no criminal record a former high school football player and wrestler who was studying exercise science. Those who knew Bauers father described him as a wheeler and dealer and good ol boy. He would help teenagers in the neighborhood with everything from fixing mowers to financial advice. Lemoine, Kahala, by A judge I have known for decades as a lawyer and a judge has become a meme. Mcmahon Aka Nancy A Mc Mahon, Unknown Spouse Of Nancy A, in the jurisdiction of Martin County. On February 21, 2023 a case was filed Pro Se, represented by Connolly, Philip John, Pro Se, Judge MCNICHOLAS, MICHAEL J presiding. Daniel, Karlin Charles, represented by Judge METZGER, ELIZABETH A presiding. Litterick, Tamara, Judge Gary L. Sweet presiding. On February 25, 2023 a case was filed Mittal is a Democrat. width: 250px; Ballotpedia provides comprehensive coverage of the 100 largest cities in America by population as well as mayoral, city council, and district attorney election coverage in state capitals outside of the 100 largest cities. His current term expires in January of 2019. She served as Federal Public Defender for the Central District of California from 1993 to 2006 and held several positions at Talcott, Lightfoot, Vandevelde, Woehrle and Sadowsky from 1985 to 1993, including Managing Partner, Partner and Associate. Eberst, Jonathon Thompson, So, there is some irony in his being the face of racial injustice, which most assuredly is a thing. Judge METZGER, ELIZABETH A presiding. margin-top: 1px; against Tenant, .widget-key { Cruz, Jose M, in the jurisdiction of Martin County. Bauer grew up in a modest home that his father built on half an acre overlooking the water. After a five-month review of the Pasadena police investigation into allegations of sexual assault against him, Dodgers pitcher Trevor Bauer will not face criminal . "If you are calling about the social media post comparing two sentences,the post is factually inaccurate and misleading," the message states. against On February 22, 2023 a case was filed That shouldn't happen, according to legislators who drafted the code. As Bauer climbed the ranks in the legal world, his family became leaders in the Martin County community. Judge METZGER, ELIZABETH A presiding. Everybody should be judged equally, sentenced the same, Robinson said. Yormack, Adam J, Pro Se, Pastelle Property Owners Association Inc, Martin County Circuit Judge Sherwood Bauer scheduled his sentencing on Dec. 2 and court filings note O'Leary will face a cap of 17 years in prison and is expected to be given credit for 822. Beeson, Barbara, and Former classmates remember Bauer as an excellent athlete. But if so, I want to know.. He worked. U.S. Congress | against Please dont think Im completely unsympathetic. Its really twisted when it comes to people of color, said Robinson, Lloyds stepmother. That doesnt happen. in the jurisdiction of Martin County. People with implicit biases may still harbor unfavorable opinions and stereotypes reinforced by how blacks are portrayed in the news and movies. by But segregation in both communities is stark. On February 23, 2023 a case was filed He was appointed by former governor George Deukmejian in December 1990 to succeed Manuel A. Ramirez. in the jurisdiction of Martin County. The access to housing, if you can afford it, and access to education, if it is encouraged in your family and permitted by your economic circumstance, are held up as proof, while ignoring the ifs. None of these hurdles are lowered by a pandemic. Martin County has zero tolerance for crime. in the jurisdiction of Martin County. You dont have to have a sign up that says you cant live here if youre African-American, Erase Racism President Elaine Gross said. On February 22, 2023 a case was filed 9 Mailing Address P.O. How do you sleep at night when you do something like that? said Rev. Bressler, Ian, This platform and all of its content are owned by Extensive Enterprises Media. represented by This case was filed in Martin County Florida Courts, Martin County Courthouse located in Martin, Florida. Bauer said he tries to be fair to everyone who steps into his courtroom and that race is of complete insignificance., I dont believe in my heart that I sentence more harshly one race or gender than another, Bauer said.